THE SCOTTISH KENNEL CLUB Oct Show held in May

Judges Critiques

Mr S A Hollings

Judging: English Setter, Gundog Group

ENGLISH SETTER

Class 1926 PD (5 Entries) Abs: 3
1st: 11374 HUGHES, Mr Graeme Mariglen Here To Eternity. Lovely head and he has shape and correct coupling. Strong bone, has depth and good rib, short loin. Smart outline and firm back to good behind and tail set, which he used well .in lovely condition.
2nd: 11375 JOHNSTONE, Mrs C & STOKES, Mr C & GILL, Mrs M Balvenie Loch Tuath. A bit long in head and could have a sweeter expression. Needs to come up on feet. He is masculine and has a very good quality coat.  needs time. 
Class 1927 JD (2 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 11392 VALLANCE, Ms M A Ennydloc Yorkshire Liaison To Rowanmyle. Smart dog that is balanced and typical in shape and outline. He has a lovely head, correct skull and ear set. Clean through his neck, firm back. Still young and need to finish, but he moved well and presented in good coat. 
2nd: 11387 STEWART, Mrs H S & QUENBY, Professor S M Tattersett Stolen Silver. Very tidy dog, just going a little wide in front today. he has balanced head and good body. Well, turned out. 

Class 1928 PGD (2 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 11389 THOMSON, Mrs K A Maursett Morganite For Caspellwynd. He has type and did his job. He has type and a good outline, could be a little untidy in front action, but looked good going round.
2nd: 11378 MCKIERNAN, Mr A M C K Bushbane Celtic Patriot. Not wanting to play here today, but this dog has strength, quality and was in lovely coat. 

Class 1929 LD (3 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 11391 VALLANCE, Ms M A Rowanmyle Was A Skellum. Masculine and well made. He has a lovely head, kind eye and good stop and strength in foreface. Elegance, strength with good bone and feet. He was in good body and coat. Sound moving using his tail well. 
2nd: 11386 STEWART, Mrs H S & QUENBY, Professor S M Tattersett Golden Sunrise. Close up to winner, as both have quality, type and are of good proportions. He is all male a good shape, with spring of rib and short loin. He moved well. Two good dogs. 
3rd: 11364 CARR, Mr Andrew & CARR, Mrs Lesley Balvenie Blue Lagoon

Class 1930 OD (4 Entries) Abs: 1
1st: 11376 MCKIERNAN, Mr A M C K Ir Sh Ch Sh Ch Bushbane Celtic Rant. Lovely dog, Masculine, so sound and has a great personality to show true English character. Fit mature and really well balanced. he was presented in grand coat and handled to show his worth. A super dog with so much breed type. I was disappointed he did not stay for the Group.  CC & BOB.
2nd: 11384 SIMPSON, Mrs Lesley & SIMPSON, Mr Douglas Dalreavoch Northern Legend. This is a really good dog showing soundness, good coupling and correct body. He is sound moving, but just not the presence of the winner. But a very worthy RES CC.
3rd: 11388 THOMSON, Mrs K A Bushbane Rathlin Caspellwynd

Class 1932 SBD (1 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 11364 CARR, Mr Andrew & CARR, Mrs Lesley Balvenie Blue Lagoon. This well-presented dog has a lovely head, strong, clean with lovely eye, stop and strength in muzzle. He stands on good legs and feet. He was sound enough on the move. A very tidy dog. 

Class 1934 PB (2 Entries) Abs: 1
1st: 11368 CORFIELD, Mrs Jackie & CORFIELD, Miss Vicki & SCHO Balvenie Loch Maree. What a lovely young bitch. She has a really good head with dark eye and sweet outlook. Well balanced and just right for body and balance in outline. Good legs and feet and turned out in a grand coat. She has personality and goes round well, need to come together coming and going, but so young, that should come with age. BPIB. 

Class 1935 JB (4 Entries) Abs: 0. A really good class, in fact best class of the day. 
1st: 11363 ALLEN, Mr Geoff & BOTT, Mr Paul & MORGAN, Mrs Ange Quensha Glitter And Gold. Striking in outline at first look with her super shape and shining rich orange coat. She is clean, elegant with nothing weak. Flows from her lovely head, through her well-made forehand and firm topline to her well placed tail. Has glamour, standing and moving. Lovely. RES CC.
2nd: 11379 PATON, Mr D & PATON, Mrs AAW Bournehouse Eternal Flame For Meadowfoot. Nothing to dislike here, a totally honest sound bitch, full of type. Feminine, clean and shapely throughout. A good head, flowing outline, well ribbed and short loin. Fit and shown in lovely coat.  Goes with true action and personality. 
3rd: 11396 WILLIAMS, Mrs P D A Bournehouse Eternal Love
Res: 11365 WALLER, Mrs Barbara Ennydloc Yorkshire Design
VHC:

Class 1936 PGB (5 Entries) Abs: 2
1st: 11370 GARDNER, Miss T Mariglen Midnight Muse Of Danwish. Really lovely bitch with a super head, neck and proportions throughout. She has balance, stands on quality legs and feet. Really fit, shapely presented in super body and coat. Goes with style and character. Can’t be far away from top honours. 
2nd: 11394 WELSH, Mrs Jennifer Goldbirch Burning Desire. A very honest typical bitch with much to like. She appeals in head and outline, nothing overdone. She is sound and presented in good coat. Perhaps not quite the balance of the winner. 
3rd: 11383 SEAMAN, Mrs B K Mariglen Villanelle.

Class 1937 LB (3 Entries) Abs: 1
1st: 12704 Mrs A GRIMSDELL Tattersett Dark Amber. Classic, sound English of correct size and balance. I found nothing to disappoint me hands on, so well put together. She has strength, bone and retains her femininity. Has body shape and correct coupling. Presented in lovely coat. A charming personality standing and moving, really pleased to award her the CC.
2nd: 11395 WILLIAMS, Mrs P D A Bournehouse Guilty Secret. Smart and sound as I would expect from this kennel. Another that has lots of quality and presents a typical picture of the breed. She is sound and free moving. A lovely bitch so well presented.

Class 1938 OB (3 Entries) Abs: 1
1st: 11377 MCKIERNAN, Mr A M C K Sh Ch Bushbane Centic Banter. Strong, shapely and in first class condition and coat. Worked with personality plus and turned out in top form throughout.
2nd: 11380 PATON, Mr D & PATON, Mrs AAW Bournehouse Secret Destiny For Meadowfoot A really lovely feminine, honest bitch of super shape and type. Totally sound and moves with positive foot placement. Perhaps not quite spirit on the move as the winner, but very hard to fault. 


Class 1940 SBB (1 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 11394 WELSH, Mrs Jennifer Goldbirch Burning Desire. Repeat. BSB.
Judge: Mr S A Hollings

BEST OF BREED : 11376 MCKIERNAN, Mr A M C K Ir Sh Ch Sh Ch Bushbane Celtic Rant
Dog CC : 11376 MCKIERNAN, Mr A M C K Ir Sh Ch Sh Ch Bushbane Celtic Rant
Res Dog CC : 11384 SIMPSON, Mrs Lesley & SIMPSON, Mr Douglas Dalreavoch Northern Legend
Bitch CC : 12704 Mrs A GRIMSDELL Tattersett Dark Amber
Res Bitch CC : 11363 ALLEN, Mr Geoff & BOTT, Mr Paul & MORGAN, Mrs Ange Quensha Glitter And Gold
Best Puppy : 11368 CORFIELD, Mrs Jackie & CORFIELD, Miss Vicki & SCHO Balvenie Loch Maree
Best Veteran :
Best Special Beginner : 11394 WELSH, Mrs Jennifer Goldbirch Burning Desire

Class 1926 PD (5 Entries) Abs: 3
1st: 11374 HUGHES, Mr Graeme Mariglen Here To Eternity
2nd: 11375 JOHNSTONE, Mrs C & STOKES, Mr C & GILL, Mrs M Balvenie Loch Tuath
3rd:
Res:
VHC:

Class 1927 JD (2 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 11392 VALLANCE, Ms M A Ennydloc Yorkshire Liaison To Rowanmyle
2nd: 11387 STEWART, Mrs H S & QUENBY, Professor S M Tattersett Stolen Silver
3rd:
Res:
VHC:

Class 1928 PGD (2 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 11389 THOMSON, Mrs K A Maursett Morganite For Caspellwynd
2nd: 11378 MCKIERNAN, Mr A M C K Bushbane Celtic Patriot
3rd:
Res:
VHC:

Class 1929 LD (3 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 11391 VALLANCE, Ms M A Rowanmyle Was A Skellum
2nd: 11386 STEWART, Mrs H S & QUENBY, Professor S M Tattersett Golden Sunrise
3rd: 11364 CARR, Mr Andrew & CARR, Mrs Lesley Balvenie Blue Lagoon
Res:
VHC:

Class 1930 OD (4 Entries) Abs: 1
1st: 11376 MCKIERNAN, Mr A M C K Ir Sh Ch Sh Ch Bushbane Celtic Rant
2nd: 11384 SIMPSON, Mrs Lesley & SIMPSON, Mr Douglas Dalreavoch Northern Legend
3rd: 11388 THOMSON, Mrs K A Bushbane Rathlin Caspellwynd
Res:
VHC:

Class 1931 VD NO ENTRIES

Class 1932 SBD (1 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 11364 CARR, Mr Andrew & CARR, Mrs Lesley Balvenie Blue Lagoon
2nd:
3rd:
Res:
VHC: 

Class 1933 GCD NO ENTRIES

Class 1934 PB (2 Entries) Abs: 1
1st: 11368 CORFIELD, Mrs Jackie & CORFIELD, Miss Vicki & SCHO Balvenie Loch Maree
2nd:
3rd:
Res:
VHC:

Class 1935 JB (4 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 11363 ALLEN, Mr Geoff & BOTT, Mr Paul & MORGAN, Mrs Ange Quensha Glitter And Gold
2nd: 11379 PATON, Mr D & PATON, Mrs AAW Bournehouse Eternal Flame For Meadowfoot
3rd: 11396 WILLIAMS, Mrs P D A Bournehouse Eternal Love
Res: 11365 WALLER, Mrs Barbara Ennydloc Yorkshire Design
VHC:

Class 1936 PGB (5 Entries) Abs: 2
1st: 11370 GARDNER, Miss T Mariglen Midnight Muse Of Danwish
2nd: 11394 WELSH, Mrs Jennifer Goldbirch Burning Desire
3rd: 11383 SEAMAN, Mrs B K Mariglen Villanelle
Res:
VHC:

Class 1937 LB (3 Entries) Abs: 1
1st: 12704 Mrs A GRIMSDELL Tattersett Dark Amber
2nd: 11395 WILLIAMS, Mrs P D A Bournehouse Guilty Secret
3rd:
Res:
VHC:

Class 1938 OB (3 Entries) Abs: 1
1st: 11377 MCKIERNAN, Mr A M C K Sh Ch Bushbane Centic Banter
2nd: 11380 PATON, Mr D & PATON, Mrs AAW Bournehouse Secret Destiny For Meadowfoot
3rd:
Res:
VHC:

Class 1939 VB NO ENTRIES

Class 1940 SBB (1 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 11394 WELSH, Mrs Jennifer Goldbirch Burning Desire
2nd:
3rd:
Res:
VHC:

Class 1941 GCB NO ENTRIES