City of Birmingham Championship Show

Judges Critiques

Mr Paul ROBINSON

Judging: German Wirehaired Pointer, Gundog Group

GERMAN WIREHAIRED POINTER

Judge: Mr P Robinson (New Zealand)

BEST OF BREED : 5830 MCCULLOUGH, Mrs M & MCCULLOUGH, Mr P Sh Ch Kimmax Koz I Kan
Best Dog : 5834 PINKERTON, Miss S & ALIMOV, Mr Viacheslav Sh Ch / Ch Matze vom Alte Wald (Imp)
Res Best Dog : 5825 GEARY, Mr Robert & GEARY, Mrs Amanda Wesley vom Alte Wald at Germanus (RAF)(NAF) (Imp)
Best Bitch : 5830 MCCULLOUGH, Mrs M & MCCULLOUGH, Mr P Sh Ch Kimmax Koz I Kan
Res Best Bitch : 5832 MORRIS, Miss S & EVANS, Mr Jonathan bareve by kind permission
Best Puppy : 5825 GEARY, Mr Robert & GEARY, Mrs Amanda Wesley vom Alte Wald at Germanus (RAF)(NAF) (Imp)
Best Veteran : 5829 LOVATT, Mrs Debbie & LOVATT, Mr Paul Ir Sh Ch Beechillawn I'm Free With Shirostar CW19
Best Junior : 5833 NEWTON, Mrs Alex GERMANUS MAKIN A RIPPLE WITH LAYASWAY
Best Special Beginner : 5838 STONE, Mrs Jenny Kenzduo Shasta

Class 2598 VD (1 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 5829 LOVATT, Mrs Debbie & LOVATT, Mr Paul Ir Sh Ch Beechillawn I'm Free With Shirostar CW19
Nicely balanced veteran dog. Balanced head with good angulation front and rear. Level topline when moving. Would prefer greater rear angulation more depth in chest. Moved nicely for a veteran dog. Veteran of Breed
Class 2599 PD (2 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 5825 GEARY, Mr Robert & GEARY, Mrs Amanda Wesley vom Alte Wald at Germanus (RAF)(NAF) (Imp)

Balanced 9-month-old male with a good front assembly. Nicely balanced overall and moved well for a young dog.  Pleasing head and expression with good spring of ribs. RDCC and POB
2nd: 5836 PINKERTON, Miss S Bareve Best Bon Jovi
Lovely balanced young male showing lots of promise. Good bone and flow showing good strength and type. At just 6 moths of age showing a lot of potential and good breed characteristics. 

Class 2601 PGD (1 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 5819 BROWN, Mrs Carole Matravers Cherokee

Good overall balance although lacking in body development. Lacking in depth of chest. Adequate hindquarters. Holds his topline well when moving and a smooth gait covering the ground well.

Class 2602 LD (1 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 5821 DONNELLY, Mr & Mrs David kimmax They Kall Me Mr Tibbs

Nicely balanced head and body. Good layback of shoulders and powerful hindquarters. Correct length to body ration with good coat condition and presentation. Smooth ground covering action with excellent carriage on the move. 


Class 2603 OD (2 Entries) Abs: 1
1st: 5834 PINKERTON, Miss S & ALIMOV, Mr Viacheslav Sh Ch / Ch Matze vom Alte Wald 

Well balanced male with good flow from neck to tail. Good substance and balance although in my view he lacked the strength of head and depth of flews. Moved well covering plenty of ground. Dog CC

Class 2605 SBB (1 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 5838 STONE, Mrs Jenny Kenzduo Shasta
Young female that lacks development and maturity. Lacking both front and rear development and depth of chest and bone. When moving is inclined to roach in her topline. Needs time to mature. Had a very sound temperament and hopefully will develop with time. 

Class 2607 PB (2 Entries) Abs: 1
1st: 5835 PINKERTON, Miss S Bareve Bananarama
Good overall balance and type. Nice head type and good front assembly and rear angles. Level topline.  Sound moving. 

Class 2608 JB (2 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 5833 NEWTON, Mrs Alex GERMANUS MAKIN A RIPPLE WITH LAYASWAY

Pleasing head. Good bone and body type with a level topline. Good depth of body. Sound moving with good reach and drive and effortless movement. Junior of Breed
2nd: 5824 GEARY, Mr Robert & GEARY, Mrs Amanda Germanus Hotwyr Minjarra:
Stands over herself well. Good balance of depth and length. Well-developed rear. Less mature than #1 although sound breed type. 
Class 2609 PGB (2 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 5824 GEARY, Mr Robert & GEARY, Mrs Amanda Germanus Hotwyr Minjarra
2nd place in the previous class. Stands over herself well. Good balance of depth and length. Well-developed rear.
Class 2610 LB (4 Entries) Abs: 1
1st: 5832 MORRIS, Miss S & EVANS, Mr Jonathan bareve by kind permission

Beautifully balanced bitch. Very pleasing head. Well developed body and both forequarters and hindquarters. Moves well and covers the ground with ease. 
2nd: 5820 DONNELLY, Mr & Mrs David Kimmax Who Kares Wins JW. RBCC
A little shorter in body than #1. Good depth of chest and hindquarters. Level topline. Short in reach of neck and less well developed hindquarters than #1. 
Class 2611 OB (2 Entries) Abs: 0
1st: 5830 MCCULLOUGH, Mrs M & MCCULLOUGH, Mr P Sh Ch Kimmax Koz I Kan

Beautifully balanced bitch with the correct front and rear angulation. Very pleasing head and reach of neck. Level topline when standing and moving. Balanced when moving where she covers the ground effortlessly. Beautifully balanced overall appearance. BCC and BOB
2nd: 5828 LOVATT, Mrs Debbie & LOVATT, Mr Paul Ir Sh Ch Beechillawn Amarillo Starlight of Shirost Adequate

Good overall balance although a little longer in body than preferred. Good front angulation and powerful and strong hindquarters. Does not have the reach of neck of #1. Covers the ground well when moving.